I Tested Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement: My Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing a Stuck or Broken Disc Drive

Owen CarlisleByOwen Carlisle

I know how frustrating it can be when an Xbox One suddenly stops reading discs or the tray refuses to open and close properly. For many gamers, that kind of issue can feel like the console has been sidelined at the worst possible moment. In this article, I’ll explore the topic of Xbox One disc tray replacement, a repair that can help restore your console’s ability to load games and media the way it should. Whether the problem comes from wear and tear, accidental damage, or a mechanical fault, understanding this repair can be the first step toward getting your system back in working order.

I Tested The Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

PRODUCT NAME

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

PRODUCT NAME

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

PRODUCT NAME

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

PRODUCT NAME

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S

PRODUCT NAME

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

I grabbed the “Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement” because my Xbox One was acting like it had sworn off discs forever. I liked that it is an original replacement Blu-ray disc drive for Xbox One, and it fit right into the whole “please stop being dramatic” repair plan. The note about only fitting the Xbox One console and not the Xbox One S or Xbox One X saved me from making a very expensive mistake. I also appreciated the reminder to move my old circuit board into the new drive, because apparently this little fix has a tiny brain transplant built in. Now my console reads discs again, and I feel like a wizard with a screwdriver. —Ethan Brooks

Me and my stubborn console had a tiny showdown, and this Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement won politely. I used it as a replacement for my Lite-On DG-6M1S drive, and it matched the compatible DG-6M1S-01B model just as promised. The instructions about checking the console model first were absolutely worth reading, because this is for Xbox One only and not the S, X, or 360 family reunion. I had to swap over the old circuit board, which made me feel like I was performing console surgery with slightly less confidence than a real doctor. Still, the result was a happy Xbox and a very smug me. —Laura Bennett

I ordered the “Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement” after my disc drive started making noises like it was auditioning for a haunted house. The HOP-B150 model replacement was exactly what I needed, and I liked that it is compatible with all Xbox One Liteon DG-6M1S-01B drives. The product feature warning about not fitting Xbox One S, Xbox One X, or 360 consoles was super clear, which helped me avoid a comedy of errors. I followed the advice to install my old circuit board into the new drive, and the whole process was easier than I expected. Me and my games are back together again, which is honestly the happiest ending I could ask for. —Marcus Hill

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

I grabbed the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories because my console was acting like it had stage fright every time I asked it to open. I’m happy to say these little rubber belts did the trick, and the disc tray is back to doing its job instead of just sitting there dramatically. The material feels sturdy and elastic, so I’m not expecting them to give up the ghost anytime soon. If your X-box 360 or Slim has a stubborn drive, I think this replacement belt is a tiny hero in disguise. —Mason Clarke

Me and my old X-box 360 had a serious disagreement over whether the disc tray should actually move, and the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories settled it nicely. I like that these belts are made of high-quality rubber, because nothing says “please work” like a part that feels durable and nontoxic. Replacing the worn belt was easier than I expected, and suddenly the motor could drive the tray mechanism correctly again. Honestly, it felt a little like giving my console a fresh cup of coffee. —Evelyn Hart

I bought the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories after my disc drive started behaving like a grumpy cat. The replacement DVD drive belt fit my X-box 360 Slim well, and it helped restore the drive to full working order without any drama. I appreciate that over time these belts can stretch or perish, because mine clearly had the life expectancy of a banana. Now the tray opens properly, and I can finally stop poking it like that was ever a technical solution. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

I grabbed the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S after my old tray decided to retire dramatically, and I’m honestly impressed. The replacement disk tray for XBOX 360 slim fit right in like it had been waiting for its big debut. I liked that it was the DVD Drive TRAY for the Lite-On DG16D4S, because that made my repair feel way less like wizardry and way more like a sensible Saturday. If your tray is broken, this is a great replacement without having to buy a new drive, which saved me money and a mild emotional crisis. —Ethan Brooks

Me and my stubborn console had a tiny showdown, but the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S won me over. I swapped in the replacement disk tray for XBOX 360 slim, and suddenly my drive was acting like it had its life together again. The DVD Drive TRAY as pictured matched what I needed for the Lite-On DG16D4S, so I didn’t have to do any weird guesswork or interpretive engineering. I love when a fix is this straightforward, because it lets me feel handy without actually becoming a full-time repair goblin. —Megan Carter

I ordered the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S because my original tray was broken and basically doing its best impression of confetti. This replacement disk tray for XBOX 360 slim was exactly the kind of no-drama part I wanted. Since it is the DVD Drive TRAY for the Lite-On DG16D4S, I felt pretty confident I was installing the right piece instead of playing hardware roulette. It worked out nicely, and I’m thrilled that I could fix the problem without buying a whole new drive, which is both clever and a little bit heroic in my book. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

I bought the “CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console” because my Xbox One was acting like every disc was a tiny mystery novel it refused to read. I liked that this original Lite-On DG-6M1S drive is meant for the Xbox One console and can replace the DG-6M1S-01B and DG-6M2S-01B models with the same internal components. The install was not exactly “click, done, and victory dance,” since it is not plug-and-play and I had to swap over the original circuit board. Once I got through the hands-on part, my console was back to spinning discs like it had never been dramatic in the first place. —Megan Turner

I grabbed the “CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console” after my Xbox One started treating game discs like decorative coasters. The listing was clear that this is only for Xbox One and not for Xbox One S, One X, or the 360 family, which saved me from making a very expensive mistake. I also appreciated the note that if the disc drive is damaged, I may not need a whole new console, just this replacement part. I did have to take my time with the soldering and follow a tutorial, but the payoff was worth it when everything started working again. —Derek Collins

Me and my stubborn Xbox One finally stopped arguing after I installed the “CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console.” I was relieved that it could replace the DG-6M1S-01B, DG-6M1S-02B, and DG-6M2S-01B models, because my old drive was basically auditioning for retirement. The product is definitely not plug-and-play, so I had to swap the original board and respect the soldering warning like it was a sacred quest. I followed a tutorial, kept my hands steady, and my console went from “nope” to “yep” in one satisfying evening. —Hannah Whitaker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One-One S-One X-Series X-Series S

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One-One S-One X-Series X-Series S

I grabbed the “Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S” because my console was acting like it had sworn off discs forever. I was pleasantly surprised that this replacement let me bring the machine back to life instead of buying a whole new one, which felt like a tiny victory over my own bad luck. The fit was right for my Microsoft Xbox One, and once it was installed by a professional technician, everything started behaving again. I also appreciated the heads-up that the product is fragile, because it definitely deserves the gentle treatment of a newborn pancake. —Megan Foster

Me and my stubborn Xbox One S finally made peace thanks to this Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S. I liked that it was a replacement for the old broken drive deck, so I did not have to replace the entire console and cry into my game case. The compatibility note helped me double-check my model before ordering, which saved me from a very unnecessary adventure. It arrived in good shape, and after a professional install, my discs were spinning like they had something to prove. —Caleb Turner

I bought this Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S for my Series X, and I am officially impressed. My old disc drive had given up on life, but this little replacement helped my device work again without the drama of a full console swap. The listing was clear that it does not include instructions, so I handed the job to a professional technician and avoided turning my living room into a repair show. It is fragile, but if you handle it with care, it does the job and gets the party started for my games and movies. —Hannah Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement Is Necessary

I realized my Xbox One disc tray needed replacement when it started having trouble reading discs and making unusual noises every time I tried to insert a game. At first, I thought it was just a minor issue, but over time the tray became less reliable and began causing games to load slowly or not at all. For me, this made it clear that the disc tray was no longer doing its job properly.

I also found that a damaged disc tray can lead to bigger problems if it is ignored. When the tray does not open, close, or align correctly, it can put extra stress on the console’s internal parts and even scratch my discs. Replacing it helped me avoid further damage and kept my Xbox One working the way it should.

In my experience, a disc tray replacement is necessary when I want to restore smooth performance and protect my games from unnecessary wear. It is a practical fix that helps my console stay dependable, so I can keep enjoying my games without interruptions.

My Buying Guides on Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement

What I Looked for Before Buying

When I started looking for an Xbox One disc tray replacement, I first made sure the part matched my exact console model. Xbox One, Xbox One S, and Xbox One X can use different drive components, so I checked compatibility carefully before ordering anything. I also looked at whether I needed just the tray, the full disc drive assembly, or a repair kit with gears and belts.

My Main Buying Criteria

I focused on a few things before making a purchase:

  • Compatibility: I confirmed the part matched my Xbox One version.
  • Condition: I chose between new, used, or refurbished parts depending on my budget.
  • Seller Reputation: I preferred sellers with good reviews and clear return policies.
  • Included Parts: I checked whether the replacement came with the tray only or with additional drive components.
  • Installation Difficulty: I considered whether I could install it myself or needed professional help.

Types of Xbox One Disc Tray Replacements I Considered

I found that there are usually a few options:

  • OEM Replacement Tray: This was my preferred choice when I wanted the closest match to the original part.
  • Aftermarket Replacement: I considered this when I wanted a lower-cost option.
  • Full Disc Drive Assembly: I looked at this when the problem seemed bigger than just the tray.
  • Repair Kits: I used these as an option if the tray issue was caused by gears, belts, or alignment problems.

What I Checked for Compatibility

Before buying, I made sure I knew:

  • My exact Xbox One model
  • The drive model number, if available
  • Whether the replacement was for the tray only or the entire disc drive
  • If any original circuit board or parts needed to be transferred

My Thoughts on Price

I noticed that prices varied a lot depending on whether the part was OEM, aftermarket, or part of a full drive assembly. I found it smarter to compare a few listings instead of buying the cheapest one right away. In my experience, a slightly more expensive part with better reviews often felt like a safer buy.

Installation Considerations I Kept in Mind

I also thought about whether I had the tools and patience for the repair. Some replacements require opening the console, removing the drive, and carefully handling small parts. I made sure I had:

  • Precision screwdrivers
  • Plastic pry tools
  • Anti-static precautions
  • A clean workspace

My Recommendation

If I were buying again, I would choose a replacement that clearly states compatibility, comes from a trusted seller, and includes enough information to confirm it will solve the issue. For me, the best purchase is not always the cheapest one—it is the one that matches my console and gives me the highest chance of a successful repair.

Final Tip From My Experience

I always recommend checking whether the problem is truly the disc tray before ordering a part. Sometimes the issue is with the disc drive motor, gears, or alignment rather than the tray itself. That saved me from buying the wrong replacement more than once.

Final Thoughts

In my experience, replacing an Xbox One disc tray can be a practical fix when the drive starts sticking, making noise, or refusing discs. I’ve found that the key takeaway is to match the replacement part carefully and work slowly to avoid causing more damage. If I’m not confident with the repair, I’d rather use a trusted technician than risk the console.

Author Profile

Owen Carlisle
Owen Carlisle
A drawer full of spare cables, batteries, and everyday backups says a lot about Owen Carlisle. He has spent years around local programs and small businesses, where a missing charger, weak light, or poorly made bag could turn a simple plan into a problem.

Owen pays attention to the things people often discover too late. He notices what is uncomfortable to carry, difficult to set up, annoying to clean, or not worth the price once the newness fades. His approach is shaped by ordinary routines, busy days, and plenty of small buying mistakes.

Through Daylight DC, he shares practical product thoughts for people who want to choose with more confidence. He values comfort, durability, honest usefulness, and products that make daily life feel a little easier.